SOLAR PLEXUS

A site devoted to to understanding the world we live in and to making a difference.

Tough Times and Hard Choices

Tough times for Israel. The whole debate over the peace process has become highly ideological and personalised. From the Left, come accusations of occupation, oppression of Palestinians and Israeli intransigence or worse. Some of this is outright wrong (the ”occupation” for instance) and much else is oversimplified and distorted. But the cry goes out: peace along the two-state paradigm is the key to Israel’s survival; at least amongst those who care a damn whether Israel survives or not. And the world, much of the Jewish Diaspora and segments of Israel believes it.

From the Right come accusations of Palestinian incitement, denial of Jewish identity and rights in the Middle East and Arab-Muslim fanaticism, backwardness and anti-Semitism. Some of this is racist and some of it is insensitive to Arab-Palestinian feelings of dispossession and humiliation. Nevertheless, there is greater truth in much of what the Right asserts, even though I don’t like the language or the refusal to see possible glimmers of opportunity.

But most Israelis are centrist. They are extremely wary of the Arab-Muslim-Palestinian world out of hard experience but are willing to concede deeply prized territory for the sake of real peace. What they deeply fear is that Israel is being pressed into a weak negotiating position for a false dream of peace and that, just around the corner after the piece of paper has been signed to much public fanfare and photo-ops, a new causus belli will be found, new grievances will be manufactured and the whole process of demonisation will continue. And after a brief interregnum of peace, hostilities will flare up, the Western and Middle East propaganda machines, only temporarily in mothballs, will be resurrected and the drive to total victory and the destruction of Israel will continue unabated.

If that happens, the world should know that millions of Jewish centrists like me will support any act by the Israeli government to ensure their security. That includes the expulsion of Palestinians from the West Bank and/or Gaza, loyalty oaths and the like. The release of 104 Palestinian prisoners with blood on their hands and the likely spectacle of Palestinian rejoicing, even gloating, is a bitter pill for Israel to swallow. What a step forward it would be if the Palestinian leadership, for once, forwent the opportunity to rub Israel’s nose in its own gesture of appeasement.

Let us all pray that it is worth it: that the moderates and peacemakers in Arab-Palestinian society will find the courage to assert themselves and that the US and the West does not continue with a policy of appeasement at the expense of Israel. Because if that happens I am sure that Israel will, once and for all, take her fate back into own hands and do what is necessary to survive and prosper.

Mike Berger

Advertisements

4 responses to “Tough Times and Hard Choices

  1. Stephen July 29, 2013 at 4:19 pm

    Accord with every word you write here. To paraphrase Yair Lapid – no happy marriage but a fair divorce – which acknowledges, and partly accommodates, both narratives. Personally I don’t think the Israeli public fears being sold down the river by Netanyahu and that is why he is actually able to engage now, although the fractured Palestinians have no such mandate. I doubt whether Israel will allow itself to be sold a crock of beans – the starry-eyed Peace Nowniks have long gone – but that is most probably what will be put on the table. So there will be no fanfares and your last paragraph will probably be the most likely outcome.

    Like

  2. Ray Melmed July 29, 2013 at 10:49 am

    Fair enough Mike – I feel that you have touched the central issues though your offering on this occasion does sound as if the enemy is almost at the door – I personally think they have quite a way to go. I am convinced that the Israeli government is serious and the committment to release 104 prisoners convicted for the deaths of hundreds of Israelis, most of whom were non-combitant men, women and children, is a clear indication of this. The left will now have their time cut out finding Natanyahu guilty for any recalcitrance the Palestinians show based on the principles that:
    1. the Palestinians are never responsible for any of their decisions or actions, no matter how outrageous or extreme, because they are only able to repond to what other do to them or drive them to do, and,
    2. perhaps the most obvious problem, Natanyahu is always wrong, regardless of what he says or does.
    We learn from his appology to Turkey over their hooligans attacking the Israeli boarding party with gun fire, knives and metal bars – that in the ME it is always possible to shift the goal posts by making more and more extreme demands. Lets see what happens.

    Like

    • Mike Berger July 29, 2013 at 10:54 am

      Wholly agree. The point I was trying to make is that if this genuine effort blows back in Israel’s face, all bets are off and I would support virtually any action that Israel feels is required to ensure its security and safety of its citizens. Mike

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: