I glance through the SA media coverage of events in Gaza, and drop right through the rabbit hole into Alice in Wonderland. But this is a strange and bizarre fantasy world in which Hamas, having instigated this conflict as rationally as it is within their power to act, in order to inflict civilian casualties on their own population so as to discredit Israel, is the victim. Many in South Africa can see through the circus theatrics, the smoke and mirrors and spin to the core reality, but the distorted messages from our media are so pervasive that the susceptible are inflamed. The Malaysian airline calamity has grabbed a good deal of the spotlight – possibly to the relief of the saner elements within the media community.
So we lurch from one ill-understood “hot topic” to another with little gain in insight and unpredictable public responses. This is the climate within all politicians operate; in many cases they are the architects. Israel is, of course, a unique case. Its frustrating success and courage is like an open wound to the haters and envious. Their whole being is consumed by the intolerable realisation that all their efforts and malice has not stopped this small, democratic, Jewish state successfully defending itself. May they continue to be consumed by the torments of hell.
This post contains two main items. The first is from my cousin Charles Smith living in Israel. He has the well-organised, realistic and precise mind of an engineer. This is his perspective on Operation Protective Edge:
Excellent articles and comment(s)
Charles’s comments are very good-afterall he is on the spot. I personally would not make any comments for fear that Charles would tear me to pieces!
LikeLike
Yes!!
LikeLike
Dear Mike,
This war is continuing and there is no clear end in sight.
We do receive a lot of information but not all. The information we receive on the damage done by our troops within Gaza is quite superficial, and contains numbers of buildings destroyed, number of casualties, almost exclusively on the Gaza side and the fact they many tunnels have been exposed. There are no exact details. It is important to realize that providing exact details will also provide the Gazan side with details of what is going on and where the Israeli troops are. Gaza may be a small area but it is still important not to provide too much information.
In Israel one subscribers having Cable or Satellite TV are able to find literally hundreds of stations including many news stations in many different languages. There are three main Israeli channels, which also provide news. One channel is government, whereas two channels are private. Over the past few days all three channels have changed their programming to continuous descriptions on what is going on (information provided by army spokesmen, reports of injured from hospitals and reports of rocket landings from all over the country) and to commentary. All these channels have excellent presenters with excellent analysts and commentators. All of them are able to show all points of view and have often managed to contact people living in Gaza. In the crazy world we live in one channel showed a film about a young Gazan girl who had been treated in the oncological department in the Rambam hospital in Haifa. She had been there 9 months accompanied by her father and was due to return to Gaza. The child who had not been home or seen her mother in 9 months was anxious to get home but when they reached the border post they were told that it was closed because of hostilities in the area.
You quite rightly stated that the best outcome of this war would be the complete defeat of Hamas. The Americans and allies did this in WWII, but the world would never let Israel attain a complete victory. This has been so in all our previous wars. The major world powers and many smaller nations can indiscriminately kill civilians. The examples are too many to mention. A relatively small number of civilians get killed either due to being in the wrong place at the wrong time or by mistake and there is a world outcry. We will have to continue to remain strong and to defend ourselves.
As to protecting ourselves, there are many air-raid shelters throughout the country but they are often not close enough and when you have a warning of 15 seconds to 2 minutes it is difficult to reach them. People have been advised to build their own safe rooms or convert other rooms into safe rooms New apartment buildings all have safe rooms. We decided about two years ago to add on a safe room to our house.There was a construction firm, who took on a number of constructions of safe rooms in or area. We are talking of a room of 3 meters by 3 meters, with wall and roof of 30 cm reinforced concrete. Their are special steel windows and doors and air vents. As this room forms part of our house, we are now protected. Over the past few days there has been one warning in our area. This was not a cheap exercise and cost us close to 100,000 shekels or about $30,000. But we are safe.
My suggestion for an outcome to the Gazan crisis would be the annexation of Gaza to Egypt. After the war of independence in 1948 Egypt ruled Gaza until the Six Day war in 1967. It was never independent. It is too small with too many people and no real means of support to be completely independent. Forming part of Egypt would allow the economy to become part of the Egyptian economy. The same would apply to the West Bank which should become part of Jordan, as it was from 1948 till 1967. However, neither Egypt or Jordan wants this burden.
Geoff
LikeLike