A site devoted to to understanding the world we live in and to making a difference.

I Like Melanie Phillips

I like Melanie Phillips. What’s not to like? She is firmly pro-Israel. Her writing is clear, informed, direct and she takes no prisoners. In Melanie’s world Israel is an oasis of democracy, innovation and sanity beset by  left-wing nincompoops, liars, anti-Semites and Islamic extremists who simply cannot come to terms with the reality of a Jewish state in what they regard as their backyard. She is a Helen Zille of journalism who never has to say “I’m sorry”.

I’m quite sure in private, MP would admit that Israel has its share of bigots and fanatics, but so what? Everyone has these and they’re kept largely in check by a functioning democracy, free media and judicial system as well as by civilised cultural norms. Who would disagree with this basic assessment, especially when set against what is going on in the region.

But her remit is broader than Israel and her basic POV is summed up in these words which appear on the Amazon blurb to her book  ‘The World Turned Upside Down: The Global Battle over God, Truth, and Power’ published in 2010:

Worst of all, asserts Phillips, this abandonment of rationality leaves the West vulnerable to its legitimate threats. Faced with the very real challenges of spiraling demographics and violent, confrontational Islamism, the West is no longer willing or able to defend the modernity and rationalism that it once brought into being.”

In a recent article she takes on leftwing tribal warriors in the USA and the West in general  who, in response to Trump’s bellicose tweet warning the blubbery maniac Kim Jong Un of North Korea to back off on the nuclear provocations, have gone ballistic.  Here is a typical headline from the liberal and generally thoughtful UK publication’ Prospect’: “Trump’s “fire and fury” threat plays straight into Kim Jong-un’s hands“.

For goodness sake! North Korea is sitting on a doomsday machine playing chicken with the world and idiots like Isobel Hilton on Prospect uses it to stoke up a bit of anti-Trumpian heat. If you want to get some idea of the basic architecture of that hair-raising, stand-off go and read Michael Totten at World Affairs Journal.

But it is worse than even Totten depicts it. While the USA and the rest of the world is deciding between Armageddon minor now rather than Armageddon major and\or on-going nuclear blackmail in a couple of year’s time and while the tribal warriors of the left are trying to make political capital out of Trumps tweets, the other geopolitical flashpoints of the world – Russia, Iran and Venezuela – are also unstable.

What is more the leaders of all these countries, and don’t let’s forget China, are well aware of both the geopolitical and domestic challenges being faced by the USA right now and see ample scope for some mischief-making of their own to advance their own interests. So when we consider the global political world and it’s interaction with domestic politics never underestimate the sheer mind-boggling complexity of the issues faced by serious leaders.

But let’s go on as if the world as we know it is not actually a runaway truck speeding along a sheer and wholly uncharted mountain pass with a gaggle of partially blind drivers pulling on the steering wheel simultaneously with all their might.

So if you want a conservative, skeptical and honest voice you cannot do better than read Melanie Phillip’s writing here. And if you want to know how the MSM is messing with your brain go here. Don’t let the interviewer put you off; it’s the interviewee, MP, who is the one to listen to.

Having praised Ms Phillips let me also say that the world is often bigger and more complex than she is willing to acknowledge. I quoted Mark Twain in a previous post  basically to the effect that simple answers to complex issues were understandable and attractive but invariably wrong. In essence, that is correct but sometimes simplicity is necessary to point out absurdity and dishonesty and MP does it to perfection.

But I want to introduce two articles before I end this post. One I have referred to in a previous post and the other is a more detailed look at the actual complexities of Jerusalem. Both are interesting and both have the potential to underpin a long and very tricky path to co-existence.

They are not quick reads but are worth at least skimming through for those who wish to get beyond the trench warfare that situations like the Israeli-Palestinian stalemate get bogged down in.  Even if they do not point the way to easy (or even realistic) solutions they both treat the Palestinians as something more than a uniform mass of bloodthirsty fanatics. That is a good thing. There will be nothing worse for Israel than becoming the mirror image of Islamic tribalism.

To end on a lighter note; if we are all on the road to oblivion let’s enjoy the ride.  So here is a really upbeat item of news: ” Israel’s Weizmann Institute of Science Ranked Sixth Worldwide in Annual Innovation Index“. Yay!!

That is a wonderful achievement.




5 responses to “I Like Melanie Phillips

  1. amweston2013 August 14, 2017 at 3:12 pm

    Great post


    Alison Weston


  2. amweston2013 August 14, 2017 at 3:01 pm

    Oh dear yet another Trump detractor. He said at the very beginning of his Presidency that if he/the US made mistakes these would be corrected and he has enough back-up to help him. He has had an unenviable time as President being attacked relentlessly on so many fronts – has any President been subjected to anything like this before? He can’t be that much of an idiot to have achieved what he has. We need politicians like him – unafraid instead of all this PC stuff.

    Melanie Phillips is the voice of reason but she has in the past been ridiculed, being called “mad Mel” by the merciless British press.


    • Syd Kaye September 3, 2017 at 11:06 pm

      Just came across your post. I should rather say : oh No. not another Trump apologist. Two more weeks have passed so perhaps you have asked yourself why everybody except for the “dispicables” who are his core constituency are Trump detractors and why he is attacked “relentlessly on all fronts” . Including from his three senior cabinet members. The reason is because he is a narcissitic head case and cannot “correct his mistakes” because he doesn’t know he makes them. To paraphrase Bertrand Russell :”The biggest fools are those that don’t know they are fools”.


  3. solarplexuss August 13, 2017 at 1:26 pm

    Hi Syd I don’t believe Melanie is a ‘caricature’. She has the strengths and weaknesses of consistency both to her loyalties and to her basically commonsensical and somewhat conservative worldview. Both of those are sorely needed at present but it limits her breadth of vision as I indicated in the final paragraphs of my post. Neither she or I would seriously argue with you about Trumps personality and limitations. There lies the pity because he initiated a much-needed change in the USA domestic narrative and foreign policy premises but doesn’t have the depth of skill to carry these programmes out properly – though let’s not underestimate the difficulties and the tone and virulence of the fightback. N Korea is a major headache because with passing time its capacity to project threat increases drastically. A suicide bomber on a regional or global scale is a new and utterly terrifying phenomenon.


  4. Syd Kaye. August 13, 2017 at 12:06 am

    The problem with Melanie Phillips is that she has become a caricature of herself. She has made good points which are music to Jewish ears with respect to Israel, Islam and the West, especially Europe, but now has a reputation to keep up.
    But she is mistaken in giving Trump any credibity whatsoever. Even if he says something which on the face of it sounds feasible, the rule ” from whence it comes” applies. Nit so long ago his every word about “the beautiful peace deal” was hung upon, and now exposed as ignorant bluster, like everything else he says.
    As far as North Korea, Mutual Assured Destruction as a doctrine still applies. North Korea does not have a first strike capability and so will not launch a nuclear attack knowing full well it will be annihilated as an immediate response. The rhetoric from them is nothing new and their strategy has been well analysed to achieve nuclear power, like Pakistani but unlike Saddam and Ghadaffi ,who were toppled through lack of it.. The UNSC has recently achieved a serious sanction resolution, agreed to by Russia and China which is a highly important diplomatic achievement, but within ten days ( which sees to be limit of his atttention span compared to the Chinese who measure strategic policy in decades ) Trump is heightening tensions which is counter productive.
    Trump has mental and/or personality disorders. One needs only to look at his facial gestures and contorted body language to know he is acting like he thinks a President should act, but without being at all convincing. He is doubling down on the Red Line error that Obama made, issuing threats he will not follow upon after his bluff is callled, and therefore undermining the power of the unspoken threat. Clearly his officials know what he is and spend their time reinterpreting his outbursts, basically saying ” ignore this idiot”. If ever he wanted to press the button, i wouldn’t be surprised if the codes were “lost” by the military.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: